Not a Woman’s Problem or a Man’s Problem

by francine on April 16, 2009 · 4 comments

in News,Patients

I’ve just read a Huffington Post article on the issues surrounding women’s health and what’s needed in health care reform. The author pointed to the fact that nearly one in five women lacks health insurance, and therefore delays care. The article, of course, is meant to draw the attention of the Obama administration to the plight of women just as we sit down to discuss reform.

Uninsured Americans are more likely not to comply with medication regimens, seek needed care, or incur further debt if they can possible help it. They are also more likely to take jobs they may not be suited for and don’t like, and hang on to these jobs “for dear life,” to use an old turn of phrase, just because of the medical benefits.

When they are laid off, they lose their insurance, and very often since they are heads of households, their children lose, too.

Trust me, this is not a woman’s problem, however. You can skew the statistics any way you like, but men have the same problem, and in this recession men are being laid off faster than women. Last month, 663,000 more people lost their jobs. I see them in every Blueprint for Survival workshop, and their first issue is always health insurance. And if it isn’t, I make sure to bring it up because it should be.

When this recession is over, we will be confronting a profoundly changed America. We may have different kinds of jobs in different kinds of companies. Who knows whether the very companies we want to create “green” jobs, most of which are small and innovative (and not rich) can afford to pay benefits? Why should they have to?

I worry about how much of what has trickled out about Obama’s reform plans still depends on the old industrial economy with its big companies (that are now going under because of their health insurance costs) and employer-sponsored benefits. Putting it back on the employer just won’t work anymore. Nor will mandating that unemployed people buy health insurance.

There’s no way I want the health care system nationalized. There’s no way I want people to stop making a living. But I do want health care made into a social enterprise, perhaps even with non-profit status. Remember when we had non-profit hospitals? Church-run hospitals? It wasn’t on the backs of the government, nor was it on the back of the employer.

The way insurance companies and drug companies have been profiting at the expense of their customers is insane and unsustainable, and is no better than the banks.

We’ve seen where greed got the banks. Greed has gotten the health care industry into the same “pickle.” Like the small community banks, we need small, non-profit community health centers. Wouldn’t that drive down the cost of health care? Can’t we treat it like a public utility?

Let’s at least discuss this — here, on Friendfeed, anywhere you want — and get some new ides on the table.

  • Pat Elliott

    I remember nonprofit hospitals. I also remember when physicians, nurses and other healthcare employees enjoyed their work and felt they made a difference.

    I remember that no one cared or seemed to get the implications when for-profit companies took over healthcare and shot down community based hospitals.

    I remember my friend who lost his CEO job when AVON (yes, the cosmetics company) bought out his hospital.

    The common denominator for the banking/healthcare situations and more is the gross financial illiteracy of the majority of Americans. Yes, getting back community control would make all the difference in the world, but only if people bothered to understand the need for preventive measures and the true costs of an illness based healthcare system.

  • Bill Teags

    1) The idea of “insurance” is to spread the risk among the largest group to minimize the costs to any single entity. Fix number one should be to get more people to pay, thus driving down the costs per entity. 'Social security medicine' – you pay when you work, you pay when self-employed, you pay when getting unemployment bene's. Down & out – you still pay $20 / month for catastrophic HC (gets the underground economy involved).

    2) Fix number two is to require preventive check-ups. Catch problems before they cost serious $$$. Encourage well-care facilities and minor-care / nurse-practitioner options that don't cost as much as emergency room visits.

    3) Fix three is to turn R&D and drug discovery back to non-profit / university / government research. New drugs should not be designed to be “blockbuster” moneymakers, but life-savers. Reagan-omics has taught business that it can drain money out of government faster than governments can do on their own, with little or no restriction.

    Socialized medicine vs capitalist medicine? We need a better middle ground than what we are currently being force-fed.

  • Pat Elliott

    I remember nonprofit hospitals. I also remember when physicians, nurses and other healthcare employees enjoyed their work and felt they made a difference.

    I remember that no one cared or seemed to get the implications when for-profit companies took over healthcare and shot down community based hospitals.

    I remember my friend who lost his CEO job when AVON (yes, the cosmetics company) bought out his hospital.

    The common denominator for the banking/healthcare situations and more is the gross financial illiteracy of the majority of Americans. Yes, getting back community control would make all the difference in the world, but only if people bothered to understand the need for preventive measures and the true costs of an illness based healthcare system.

  • Bill Teags

    1) The idea of “insurance” is to spread the risk among the largest group to minimize the costs to any single entity. Fix number one should be to get more people to pay, thus driving down the costs per entity. 'Social security medicine' – you pay when you work, you pay when self-employed, you pay when getting unemployment bene's. Down & out – you still pay $20 / month for catastrophic HC (gets the underground economy involved).

    2) Fix number two is to require preventive check-ups. Catch problems before they cost serious $$$. Encourage well-care facilities and minor-care / nurse-practitioner options that don't cost as much as emergency room visits.

    3) Fix three is to turn R&D and drug discovery back to non-profit / university / government research. New drugs should not be designed to be “blockbuster” moneymakers, but life-savers. Reagan-omics has taught business that it can drain money out of government faster than governments can do on their own, with little or no restriction.

    Socialized medicine vs capitalist medicine? We need a better middle ground than what we are currently being force-fed.

Previous post:

Next post: